Published On: Sat, Jun 20th, 2020

Interview: Apple’s Schiller says position on Hey app is unvaried and no manners changes are imminent

In a brief call now about Basecamp’s Hey email app from a iOS App Store, Apple’s Phil Schiller told me that there would now be no changes to a manners that would concede a app to continue to be offered.

“Sitting here today, there’s not any changes to a manners that we are considering,” Schiller said. “There are many things that they could do to make a app work within a manners that we have. We would adore for them to do that.”

The call came after several days of open inspection of Apple’s doing of a Hey app. After an initial approval, a developers during Basecamp, including dual of a founders, David Heinemeier Hansson and Jason Fried, took to Twitter to note that an refurbish had been regularly rejected, with a core of a evidence being that they were not charity an in-app squeeze for a full use in further to charity it on a Hey website.

The stream knowledge of a Hey app as a user downloading it from a App Store is that it does nothing. It is an app that requires we to concede to a Hey use on a web before it becomes useful.

“You download a app and it doesn’t work, that’s not what we wish on a store,” says Schiller. This, he says, is since Apple requires in-app purchases to offer a same purchasing functionality as they would have elsewhere.

To be clear, this is opposite a App Store manners for many apps. The exceptions here are apps that are noticed as “readers” that usually arrangement outmost ease of certain types, like music, books and cinema — and apps that usually offer bulk pricing options that are paid for by institutions or companies rather than a finish user.

Schiller is transparent on a call that Hey does not fit these rules.

“We didn’t extend these exceptions to all software,” he records about a “reader” form apps — examples of that embody Netflix. “Email is not and has never been an difference enclosed in this rule.”

In fact, Hey’s Mac App was deserted for a accurate duty for that a iOS app is being targeted. Schiller says that a iOS app’s strange chronicle was authorized in error, and should never have shipped to a store.

The questions, then, unequivocally core around either this should be a case, rather than is there some arrange of keen prophesy of a stream App Store manners that would concede a Hey app to continue to be on a store.

I asked Schiller if this meant Apple felt entitled to a apportionment of a income of each business that had an app, regardless of either that business was an iOS-first.

“I get since there’s a doubt here,” he says. “But that’s not what we’re doing.”

Schiller says that there are a series of decisions about how to assign business that Basecamp could have done to make a app excusable underneath stream rules. He lists several, including charging opposite prices in a app and on a web, and charity a giveaway chronicle with additional functions.

But, he says, if you’re going to assign for it and it is a digital service, afterwards Apple wants developers to use a in-app squeeze automechanic and Apple remuneration complement to safeguard that users have a good knowledge in a app and that a remuneration complement is secured.

One proceed that Hey could have gone, Schiller says, is to offer a giveaway or paid chronicle of a app with elementary email reading facilities on a App Store, afterwards alone charity an upgraded email use that worked with a Hey app on iOS on a possess website. Schiller gives one some-more example: an RSS app that reads any feed, yet also reads an upgraded feed that could be charged for on a apart site. In both cases, a apps would have functionality when downloaded on a store.

Other options are some-more informed to many users, that includes a totally giveaway app with an upsell that is also an in-app purchase.

Unfortunately, of course, a stream manners would forestall Hey from promotion or even mentioning any upgraded service, and that would have to be marketed by off-app channels.

The ongoing discuss around a emanate is summed adult good by Sarah Perez on TechCrunch yesterday and we inspire we to review that if you’re not adult to date. And only now a story in a Times landed about Facebook’s gaming app carrying been deserted for manners 5 times. All of this brewing a ideal charge in allege of Apple’s WWDC discussion directed during developers and scarcely day and date with a launch of an EU antitrust investigation.

I’ve been meditative tough about it myself, as someone who covers Apple extensively and has mostly been declare to a behind-the-scenes stress that developers have about either Apple will reject an app from one impulse to a successive since of a personal interpretation of a App Store rules.

I cruise that, for me, it boils down to some elementary observations. The fact is that Hey violates app store rules. Which means that a doubt is not “how can we melt those manners or flicker adequate to clear it” yet instead “should those be a rules”?

As distant as to since Apple would demeanour during a conditions like this and not see an apparent minefield, we trust that it internally thinks that it is doing a right and only thing. It built a platform, it deserves to distinction from that height that does minister huge mercantile impact to both digital and earthy sectors. And there are undoubted confidence and remoteness advantages to Apple determining a payments platform.

And for those that would contend “but certainly it sees a optics!” we cruise that those people mostly blink a energy of scale. Apple approves some 100,000 apps each week and a immeasurable infancy of rejections are for teenager issues fast fixed. That kind of scale can mostly hook notice on interest of an classification and a running forces, since they see a immeasurable ease sea with a few breakers — where a media is focused on a breakers alone.

Here’s how we feel about that, though, and where a blind spots might distortion here.

  1. There might be (and my behind channel, and other people’s behind channels, prove that there is) a vast belligerent bloat of rancour and exasperation with a App Store that goes un-expressed since people are fearful and need it to survive.
  2. Sometimes a source of a critique matters — Hansson might be irritating and assertive and takes a worst-motivations position in his open comms, yet change and self hearing do not always emanate with people who we cruise to be a friends or allies. And it is twice as tough to request a change that comes from people who are indignant and clearly unpleasant — yet maybe right.

Call me naive, yet we do feel that there is a superset of genuine, core values that Apple does apply to a business in a proceed that is honestly singular among large corporations. I’m certain some people will remonstrate (read: many) yet I’ve seen it first-hand in covering a association and in discussions (official and personal) with many, many, many of a executives and arrange and record employees over a years. Much like John Gruber we find it tough to block a round with anticipating a proceed brazen here that sets aside “we are doing what is right” for “what is a right thing to do”?

Shortly before edition this interview, Apple supposing a minute to TechCrunch that was also sent to Fried and Hey.

The minute reiterates a reasons Apple says that Hey does not approve with stream App Store policy. It reads, in part:

“Thank we for being an iOS app developer. We know that Basecamp has grown a series of apps and many successive versions for a App Store for many years, and that a App Store has distributed millions of these apps to iOS users. These apps do not offer in-app squeeze — and, consequently, have not contributed any income to a App Store over a final 8 years. We are happy to continue to support we in your app business and offer we a solutions to yield your services for giveaway — so prolonged as we follow and honour a same App Store Review Guidelines and terms that all developers contingency follow.”

So for now, no thawing.

Full minute follows:

Hello Jason,

We are essay to let we know a interest formula for your app, HEY Email.

The App Review Board evaluated your app and dynamic that a rejecting was valid. Your app does not approve with a App Store Review Guidelines minute below. As we are aware, this is a reason your Hey Email app was deserted when it was submitted to a Mac App Store on Jun 11, 2020.

The HEY Email app is marketed as an email app on a App Store, yet when users download your app, it does not work. Users can't use a app to entrance email or perform any useful duty until after they go to a Basecamp website for Hey Email and squeeze a permit to use a HEY Email app. This violates a following App Store Review Guidelines:

Guideline 3.1.1 – Business – Payments – In-App Purchase

If we wish to clear facilities or functionality within your app, we contingency use in-app purchase. Your app requires business to squeeze content, subscriptions, or facilities outward of a app, yet those equipment are not accessible as in-app purchases within a app as compulsory by a App Store Review Guidelines.

Guideline 3.1.3(a) – Business – Payments – “Reader” Apps

Reader apps might concede users to entrance formerly purchased ease and ease subscriptions. Your mail app is not one of a ease forms authorised underneath this guideline for “Reader” apps (specifically: magazines, newspapers, books, audio, music, video, entrance to veteran databases, VOIP, cloud storage, or authorized services such as classroom government apps). Therefore, business contingency be given a choice to squeeze entrance to facilities or functionality in your app regulating in-app purchase.

Guideline 3.1.3(b) – Business – Payments – Multiplatform Services

Apps that work services opposite mixed platforms might concede users to entrance content, subscriptions, or facilities they have acquired in your app on other platforms or on your website, supposing those equipment are also accessible as in-app purchases within a app. Your HEY Email app does not offer entrance to content, subscriptions, or facilities as in-app purchases within a app. In fact, a app does not duty as an email app or for any purpose until a user goes to a Basecamp Hey Email website to start a giveaway hearing or squeeze a apart permit to use a app for a dictated purpose.

Next Steps

To solve this issue, greatfully correct your app such that it does not violate any of a App Store Review Guidelines and terms.

There are a series of ways that we could correct your app or use to belong to a App Store Review Guidelines. Customers who have formerly purchased entrance to content, subscriptions, or facilities elsewhere might continue to entrance these equipment in your app, as prolonged as new iOS business are given a choice to squeeze entrance regulating in-app squeeze as compulsory by a App Store Review Guidelines.

If we would cite not to offer users a choice of in-app purchases, we could cruise carrying a app duty as marketed — an email customer that works with customary IMAP and POP email accounts, where business can optionally configure a Hey Email use as their elite email use provider. This would concede a app to duty as an email customer but requiring an additional remuneration to use a facilities and functionality. Under this approach, what we sell on your website is clearly an email use apart from a duty of your app as distributed on a App Store.

We are here as a apparatus as we try these or other ideas to move a Hey Email app within correspondence of a App Store Review Guidelines and terms.

Thank we for being an iOS app developer. We know that Basecamp has grown a series of apps and many successive versions for a App Store for many years, and that a App Store has distributed millions of these apps to iOS users. These apps do not offer in-app squeeze — and, consequently, have not contributed any income to a App Store over a final 8 years. We are happy to continue to support we in your app business and offer we a solutions to yield your services for giveaway — so prolonged as we follow and honour a same App Store Review Guidelines and terms that all developers contingency follow.

We wish to support we in charity a Hey Email app on a App Store.

Sincerely,

App Review Board

About the Author