Published On: Wed, Aug 5th, 2020

Google-Fitbit understanding to be scrutinized in Europe over information foe concerns

In a shock for Google’s devise to acquire health wearable association Fitbit, a European Commission has announced it’s opening an examination to puncture into a operation of foe concerns being trustworthy to a offer from mixed quarters.

This means a understanding is on ice for a duration of time that could final until early December.

The Commission pronounced it has 90 operative days to take a preference on a partnership — so until Dec 9, 2020.

Commenting on opening an “in-depth investigation” in a statement, Commission EVP Margrethe Vestager — who heads adult both foe routine and digital devise for a confederation — said: “The use of wearable inclination by European consumers is approaching to grow significantly in a entrance years. This will go palm in palm with an exponential enlargement of information generated by these devices. This information provides pivotal insights about a life and a health conditions of a users of these devices.Our examination aims to safeguard that control by Google over information collected by wearable inclination as a outcome of a transaction does not crush competition.”

Google has responded to a EU stop on a ambitions with a blog post in that a inclination services arch seeks to urge a deal, arguing it will coax creation and lead to augmenting competition.

“This understanding is about devices, not data,” Google VP Rick Osterloh serve claims.

The tech hulk announced a enterprise to trip into Fitbit’s data-sets behind in November, when it announced a devise to bombard out $2.1BN in an all-cash understanding to collect adult a wearable maker.

Fast brazen a few months and CEO Sundar Pichai is being taken to charge by lawmakers on home territory for things like ‘helping destroy anonymity on a Internet‘. Last year’s already unruly antitrust drum kick around vast tech has turn a full on stone festival so a mood song around tech acquisitions competence finally be shifting.

Since news of Google’s devise to fist Fitbit forsaken concerns about a understanding have been lifted all over Europe — with consumer groups, remoteness regulators and foe and tech routine wonks all sounding a alarm during a awaiting of vouchsafing a adtech hulk cackle a device builder and assistance itself to a garland of supportive consumer health information in a process.

Digital remoteness rights group, Privacy International — one of a not-for-profits that’s been propelling regulators not to rubberstamp a understanding — argues a partnership would not usually fist foe in a nascent digital health market, and also for wearables, though also revoke “what small vigour there now is on Google to contest in propinquity to remoteness options accessible to consumers (both existent and destiny Fitbit users), heading to even reduction foe on remoteness standards and thereby enabling a serve plunge of consumers’ remoteness protections”, as it puts it.

So most sound is being done that Google has already played a ‘we guarantee not to…’ label that’s a favorite of data-mining tech giants. (Typically followed, a few years later, with a ‘we got ya sucker’ buffoon — as they go forward and do a thing they totally pronounced they wouldn’t.)

To wit: From a get-go Fitbit has claimed users’ “health and wellness information will not be used for Google ads”. Just like WhatsApp pronounced zero would change when Facebook bought them. (Er.)

Last month Reuters revisited a concession, in an “exclusive” news that cited “people informed with a matter” who apparently told it a understanding could be waved by if Google affianced not to use Fitbit information for ads.

It’s not transparent where a trickle underpinning a news news came from though Reuters also ran with a quote from a Google mouthpiece — who serve claimed: “Throughout this routine we have been transparent about a joining not to use Fitbit health and wellness information for Google ads and a shortcoming to yield people with choice and control with their data.”

In a event, Google’s headline-grabbing promises to act itself with Fitbit information have not prevented EU regulators from wading in for a closer demeanour during foe concerns — that is accurately as it should be.

In truth, given a turn of regard now being lifted about tech giants’ marketplace energy and adtech hulk Google privately grabbing a value trove of consumer health data, a extensive examine is a really slightest regulators should be doing.

If digital routine story has shown anything over a past decade+ (and where information is concerned) it’s that a demon is always in a excellent imitation detail. Moreover a quick gait of digital markets can meant a rival hazard might usually be a micro focus divided from materializing. Theories of mistreat clearly need updating to take comment of data-mining technosocial height giants. And a Commission knows that — that is since it’s consulting on giving itself some-more powers to rebellious tipping in digital markets. But it also needs to flex and practice a powers it now has. Such as opening a correct examination — rather than gaily fluttering tech hulk deals through.

Antitrust might now be season of a month where tech giants are endangered — with US lawmakers all though dogmatic fight on digital ‘robber barons’ during final month’s vast subcommittee showdown in Congress. But it’s also value observant that EU foe regulators — for all their heavily publicized speak of scrupulously controlling a digital globe — have nonetheless to retard a singular digital tech merger.

It stays to be seen either that record will change come December.

“The Commission is endangered that a due transaction would serve barricade Google’s marketplace position in a online promotion markets by augmenting a already immeasurable volume of information that Google could use for personalisation of a ads it serves and displays,” it writes in a press recover today.

Following a rough comment routine of a deal, EU regulators pronounced they have concerns about [emphasis theirs]:

  • “the impact of a transaction on a supply of online hunt and arrangement promotion services (the sale of promotion space on, respectively, a outcome page of an internet hunt engine or other internet pages)”
  • and on “the supply of ‘ad tech’ services (analytics and digital collection used to promote a programmatic sale and squeeze of digital advertising)”

“By appropriation Fitbit, Google would acquire (i) a database confirmed by Fitbit about a users’ health and fitness; and (ii) a record to rise a database identical to Fitbit’s one,” a Commission serve notes.

“The information collected around wrist-worn wearable inclination appears, during this theatre of a Commission’s examination of a transaction, to be an critical advantage in a online promotion markets. By augmenting a data advantage of Google in a personalisation of a ads it serves around a hunt engine and displays on other internet pages, it would be some-more formidable for rivals to compare Google’s online promotion services. Thus, a transaction would lift barriers to entrance and enlargement for Google’s competitors for these services, to a ultimate wreckage of advertisers and publishers that would face aloft prices and have reduction choice.”

The Commission views Google as widespread in a supply of online hunt promotion services in roughly all EEA (European Economic Area) countries; as good as holding “a clever marketplace position” in a supply of online promotion arrangement services in a vast series of EEA countries (especially off-social network arrangement ads), and “a clever marketplace position” in a supply of adtech services in a EEA.

All of that will surprise a considerations as it looks during either Google will benefit an astray rival advantage by assimilating Fitbit data. (Vestager has also released a series of antitrust enforcements opposite a tech hulk in new years, opposite Android, AdSense and Google Shopping.)

The regulator has also pronounced it will serve demeanour at:

  • the “effects of a multiple of Fitbit’s and Google’s databases and capabilities in a digital medical sector, that is still during a nascent theatre in Europe”
  • “whether Google would have a ability and inducement to reduce a interoperability of rivals’ wearables with Google’s Android handling complement for smartphones once it owns Fitbit”

The tech hulk has already offering EU regulators one specific benefaction in a hopes of removing a Fitbit buy immature illuminated — with a Commission observant that it submitted commitments directed during addressing concerns final month.

Google suggested formulating a information silo to reason information collected around Fitbit’s wearable inclination — and where it pronounced it would be kept apart from any other dataset within Google (including claiming it would be limited for ad purposes). However a Commission expresses questioning about Google’s offer, essay that it “considers that a information silo joining due by Google is deficient to clearly boot a critical doubts identified during this theatre as to a effects of a transaction”.

“Among others, this is since a information silo pill did not cover all a information that Google would entrance as a outcome of a transaction and would be profitable for promotion purposes,” it added.

Google creates anxiety to this information silo in a blog post, claiming: “We’ve been transparent from a commencement that we will not use Fitbit health and wellness information for Google ads. We recently offering to make a legally contracting joining to a European Commission per a use of Fitbit data. As we do with all a products, we will give Fitbit users a choice to review, pierce or undo their data. And we’ll continue to support far-reaching connectivity and interoperability opposite a and other companies’ products.”

“We conclude a event to work with a European Commission on an proceed that addresses consumers’ expectations of their wearable devices. We’re assured that by operative closely with Fitbit’s group of experts, and bringing together a knowledge in AI, program and hardware, we can build constrained inclination for people around a world,” it adds.

About the Author